The Revenge of the Intuitive – Brian Eno featured in Wired

May 16, 2011 · Posted in Uncategorized 

I recently spent three days working with what is possibly the most advanced recording console in the world, and I have to report that it was a horribly unmusical experience. The console, which has more than 10,000 controls on its surface and a computer inside, was designed in such a way that music-making tasks once requiring a single physical switch now require a several-step mental negotiation. My engineer kept saying “Wait a minute” and then had to duck out of the musical conversation we were having so he could go into secretarial mode to execute complex computer-like operations. It’s as though a new layer of bureaucracy has interposed itself between me and the music we want to make. After days of tooth-gnashing frustration, I had to admit that something has gone wrong with the design of technology – and I was paying $2,000 a day in studio fees to discover it.

Years ago I realized that the recording studio was becoming a musical instrument. I even lectured about it, proclaiming that “by turning sound into malleable material, studios invite you to construct new worlds of sounds as painters construct worlds of form and color.” I was thrilled at how people were using studios to make music that otherwise simply could not exist. Studios opened up possibilities. But now I’m struck by the insidious, computer-driven tendency to take things out of the domain of muscular activity and put them into the domain of mental activity. This transfer is not paying off. Sure, muscles are unreliable, but they represent several million years of accumulated finesse. Musicians enjoy drawing on that finesse (and audiences respond to its exercise), so when muscular activity is rendered useless, the creative process is frustrated. No wonder artists who can afford the best of anything keep buying “retro” electronics and instruments, and revert to retro media.

The trouble begins with a design philosophy that equates “more options” with “greater freedom.” Designers struggle endlessly with a problem that is almost nonexistent for users: “How do we pack the maximum number of options into the minimum space and price?” In my experience, the instruments and tools that endure (because they are loved by their users) have limited options.

Software options proliferate extremely easily, too easily in fact, because too many options create tools that can’t ever be used intuitively. Intuitive actions confine the detail work to a dedicated part of the brain, leaving the rest of one’s mind free to respond with attention and sensitivity to the changing texture of the moment. With tools, we crave intimacy. This appetite for emotional resonance explains why users – when given a choice – prefer deep rapport over endless options. You can’t have a relationship with a device whose limits are unknown to you, because without limits it keeps becoming something else.

Indeed, familiarity breeds content. When you use familiar tools, you draw upon a long cultural conversation – a whole shared history of usage – as your backdrop, as the canvas to juxtapose your work. The deeper and more widely shared the conversation, the more subtle its inflections can be.

This is the revenge of traditional media. Even the “weaknesses” or the limits of these tools become part of the vocabulary of culture. I’m thinking of such stuff as Marshall guitar amps and black-and-white film – what was once thought most undesirable about these tools became their cherished trademark.

The Marshall guitar amplifier doesn’t just get louder when you turn it up. It distorts the sound to produce a whole range of new harmonics, effectively turning a plucked string instrument into a bowed one. A responsible designer might try to overcome this limitation – probably the engineers at Marshall tried, too. But that sound became the sound of, among others, Jimi Hendrix. That sound is called “electric guitar.” Or think of grainy black-and-white film, or jittery Super 8, or scratches on vinyl. These limitations tell you something about the context of the work, where it sits in time, and by invoking that world they deepen the resonances of the work itself.

Since so much of our experience is mediated in some way or another, we have deep sensitivities to the signatures of different media. Artists play with these sensitivities, digesting the new and shifting the old. In the end, the characteristic forms of a tool’s or medium’s distortion, of its weakness and limitations, become sources of emotional meaning and intimacy.

Although designers continue to dream of “transparency” – technologies that just do their job without making their presence felt – both creators and audiences actually like technologies with “personality.” A personality is something with which you can have a relationship. Which is why people return to pencils, violins, and the same three guitar chords.

Via Wired

Tags:

Comments

Leave a Reply




  • New stuff



    LISTEN TO THE NEW STEELBERRY CLONES SINGLES ON SOUNDCLOUD (click the images below)



    LISTEN TO THE NEW ELECTRONICALLY YOURS ALBUM ON SPOTIFY (click the image below)

    MUSIC FROM OUR READERS
    Promote your electronic music at Stereoklang by Stereoklang Produktion
    Send us your sounds

  • STEREOKLANG HOME


  • Playlist

    New and recommended by Stereoklang Latest entries first.

    • Covenant: “Last Dance EP”
    • Nine Inch Nails: “Came Back Haunted”
    • Marnie: “The Hunter”
    • Jenn Vix and Dirk Ivens: “Burn”
    • Chvrches: “Gun”
    • Front Line Assembly: “Echogentic”
    • Download: “LingAM”
    • Thyx: “Below the City”
    • Visage: “Hearts and Knives”
    • Alison Moyet: “Filigree”
    • Noblesse Oblige: “Runaway”
    • Pet Shop Boys: “Electric”
    • Zynic: “Dead End (Club Mix by Olaf Wollschläger”
    • Informatik: “World of Wonder”
    • Skinny Puppy: “Weapon”
    • Displacer: “Curse of the Black Lotus”
    • Marsheaux: “Inhale”
    • Pouppée Fabrikk: “The Dirt”
    • OMD: “English Electric”
    • Chvrches: “Recover”
    • Pouppée Fabrikk: “Bring Back the Days of Old”
    • IAMX: “The Unified Field”
    • M83 feat. Susanne Sundfør: “Oblivion”
    • Code 64: “Accelerate EP”
    • Depeche Mode: “Delta Machine”
    • Kite: “The Rhythm” (song) • How to Destroy Angels: “Welcome Oblivion”
    • Hurts “Exile”
    • DSX: “Anonymous EP”
    • KMFDM: “Kunst”
    • Klinik: “Eat Your Heart out”
    • Diorama: “Even the Devil Doesn’t Care”
    • OMD: “Metroland”
    • Interdiction: “Novus Ordo Seclorum”
    • Mesh: “Automation Baby”
    • Trakktor: “Halo of Lies”
    • Depeche Mode: “Heaven”
    • The Knife: “Full of Fire”
    • Röyksopp feat Susanne Sundfør: “Running to the Sea”
    • Titans: “My Sorrow”
    • Lindstrøm: “Fāār-i-kāāl”
    • CHVRCHES: “The Mother We Share”
    • IAMX: “The Unified Field – Radio Edit”
    • Mesh: “Born to Lie”
    • Ohm: “Car Crash”
    • Syntax: “Tripolar”
    • Iamamiwhoami: “Kin”
    • Die Krupps: “Risikofaktor”
    • Legend: “Fearless”
    • The Prodigy: “The Fat of the Land
    • Dead When I Found Her: “Ragdoll Blues”
    • Hocico: “Vile Whispers”
    • Front Line Assembly: “AirMech”
    • Velvet Acid Christ: “Maldire”
    • Rome: “Hell Money”
    • “Bleep – A Guide To Electronic Music”
    • The Birthday Massacre: “Hide and Seek”
    • Karin Park: “Highwire Poetry”
    • X Marks the Pedwalk: “The Sun, The Cold and My Underwater Fear”
    • Delerium: “Music Box Opera”
    • Not Lars: “Worry”
    • Katatonia: “Dead End Kings”
    • Bossa Machine: “The Fat and Ugly Man EP”
    • Marlow: “No Heart”
    • Mr Meeble: “Liar”
    • Grendel: “Epr // Edp”
    • In Strict Confidence: “Morpheus (Heqc Remix)”

  • Loops and more

  • Recommended free SW stuff



    Camel Audio – Alchemy Player


    U-He – TyrellN6


    U-He – Zebralette


    Applied Acoustics Systems – Swatches


    IK Media – AmpliTube 3 Free


    Reaper DAW


  • Partners

  • Magazines













  • Sponsors

Get Adobe Flash player